When considering organic search versus paid ads on Google, it’s crucial to understand both strategies are integral to a comprehensive digital marketing approach. Here’s an in-depth comparison to guide you:
| Aspect | Organic Search | Paid Ads (Google Ads) |
|---|---|---|
| Definition | Organic search refers to the unpaid listings in search engine results pages (SERPs) that are determined by the search engine’s algorithms. It relies on SEO (Search Engine Optimization) to naturally rank high. | Paid ads are listings that appear at the top of SERPs because an advertiser has paid for them. They are driven by PPC (Pay-Per-Click) campaigns, where advertisers bid on keywords. |
| Similarities | Both aim to increase visibility and drive traffic to websites. They are based on keywords and rely heavily on relevance to the user’s search query. | Both offer analytics and tracking tools to monitor performance and require a strategic approach to target specific audiences. |
| Differences | Organic search is a long-term strategy. Results grow over time and are more sustainable. It’s influenced by numerous factors like site authority, content quality, and user engagement. | Paid ads provide immediate visibility and can be highly targeted. Advertisers have control over the placement and format of their ads. |
| Pros |
|
|
| Cons |
|
|
When to Use Paid Ads
Paid ads should be used when:
- Launching New Products/Services: To gain instant visibility and drive awareness.
- Targeting Specific Keywords: Especially those that are highly competitive in organic search.
- Time-Sensitive Promotions: To ensure the promotion gets seen during the limited time frame.
- Remarketing: To target users who have already shown interest in your products or services.
- To Supplement Organic Efforts: Especially in areas where your organic reach is not strong.
CASE STUDY: THE HIGH-FASHION E-RETAILER
Consider a high-fashion e-retailer launching a new line. They already have a robust SEO strategy that brings in substantial organic traffic, but for this launch, they need immediate visibility.
- Organic Strategy: Continuation of their content marketing with blogs, influencer collaborations, and SEO optimization for the new line.
- Paid Ads Strategy: We created a PPC campaign targeting high-intent keywords and utilizing display ads to retarget visitors who engaged with the new line but didn’t purchase.
The key to success was the selection of keywords to be targeted.
High-volume keywords had a high price but were a perfect match. The company was willing to pay the price. But in our experience, bidding on a higher price does not mean higher conversation.
On the other hand keyword bidding for a low-volume keyword also will not yield results.
We suggested the ‘long tail keywords’ option and selected the best 10 keywords to bid for. The keywords were with a purchase intent and had a decent traffic on Google.
Result: The paid ads drove immediate traffic and sales, while the organic strategy ensured a sustained interest post-launch, building brand authority and customer loyalty.
Ultimately, the choice between organic search and paid ads is not binary. A holistic marketing strategy often involves leveraging both to achieve both short-term goals and long-term growth. It’s not about choosing one over the other but understanding when and how to use each effectively in the digital marketing landscape.
